array:66 [
  "id" => "13116"
  "pid" => "12"
  "tstamp" => "1645298165"
  "headline" => "Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung"
  "alias" => "verbilligte-vermietung-einer-wohnung"
  "author" => "von unsem Gastkommentator"
  "date" => "30.05.2022"
  "time" => "1653868860"
  "subheadline" => ""
  "teaser" => "<p>Aufwendig gestaltete Wohngebäude: Verbilligte Vermietung an Angehörige besser vermeiden.</p>"
  "addImage" => true
  "overwriteMeta" => ""
  "singleSRC" => "files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg"
  "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "imageTitle" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "size" => "a:3:{i:0;s:0:"";i:1;s:0:"";i:2;s:0:"";}"
  "imagemargin" => "a:5:{s:6:"bottom";s:0:"";s:4:"left";s:0:"";s:5:"right";s:0:"";s:3:"top";s:0:"";s:4:"unit";s:0:"";}"
  "imageUrl" => ""
  "fullsize" => false
  "caption" => ""
  "floating" => "above"
  "addEnclosure" => ""
  "enclosure" => []
  "source" => "default"
  "jumpTo" => "0"
  "articleId" => "0"
  "url" => "https://www.marketsteel.de/files/recht/Steuerausblick%202021.pdf"
  "target" => ""
  "cssClass" => ""
  "noComments" => ""
  "featured" => ""
  "published" => "1"
  "start" => "1653868800"
  "stop" => ""
  "lazyDisable" => ""
  "syncArchive" => "8"
  "uuid" => "d46ddc04-973d-4b98-853b-7300fa09898e"
  "class" => " news_category_22 category_22"
  "newsHeadline" => "Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung"
  "subHeadline" => ""
  "hasSubHeadline" => false
  "linkHeadline" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/verbilligte-vermietung-einer-wohnung.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung" itemprop="url">Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung</a>"
  "more" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/verbilligte-vermietung-einer-wohnung.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung" itemprop="url">read more<span class="invisible"> Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung</span></a>"
  "link" => "steuer-recht-details/verbilligte-vermietung-einer-wohnung.html"
  "archive" => NewsArchiveModel {#502
    #arrData: array:27 [
      "id" => "12"
      "tstamp" => "1605357702"
      "title" => "DE - Recht"
      "jumpTo" => "95"
      "protected" => ""
      "groups" => null
      "allowComments" => ""
      "notify" => "notify_admin"
      "sortOrder" => "ascending"
      "perPage" => "0"
      "moderate" => ""
      "bbcode" => ""
      "requireLogin" => ""
      "disableCaptcha" => ""
      "categories" => null
      "limitCategories" => "0"
      "syncFilesDir" => b")LÃѧo\x11ê—×Hß7\x1C7P"
      "syncUpdate" => ""
      "syncCron" => ""
      "ignoreDuplicateAliases" => ""
      "syncUnpublished" => ""
      "syncLimitCategories" => null
      "syncArchives" => "a:1:{i:0;s:1:"8";}"
      "syncSourceUrl" => "http://de.market-steel.com"
      "syncTarget" => "1"
      "syncFixRelativeUrls" => ""
      "syncSource" => ""
    ]
    #arrModified: []
    #arrRelations: array:2 [
      "jumpTo" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_page"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasOne"
        "load" => "eager"
      ]
      "groups" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_member_group"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasMany"
        "load" => "lazy"
      ]
    ]
    #arrRelated: array:1 [
      "jumpTo" => PageModel {#418
        #blnDetailsLoaded: true
        #arrData: array:80 [
          "id" => "95"
          "pid" => "30"
          "sorting" => "128"
          "tstamp" => "1604347139"
          "title" => "Steuer & Recht Details"
          "alias" => "steuer-recht-details"
          "type" => "regular"
          "pageTitle" => ""
          "language" => "de"
          "robots" => "index,follow"
          "description" => null
          "redirect" => "permanent"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "redirectBack" => ""
          "url" => ""
          "target" => ""
          "dns" => ""
          "staticFiles" => ""
          "staticPlugins" => ""
          "fallback" => ""
          "adminEmail" => ""
          "dateFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "timeFormat" => "H:i:s"
          "datimFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "createSitemap" => ""
          "sitemapName" => ""
          "useSSL" => ""
          "autoforward" => ""
          "protected" => false
          "groups" => false
          "includeLayout" => ""
          "layout" => "9"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "includeCache" => ""
          "cache" => "43200"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "includeChmod" => ""
          "cuser" => "0"
          "cgroup" => "0"
          "chmod" => "a:9:{i:0;s:2:"u1";i:1;s:2:"u2";i:2;s:2:"u3";i:3;s:2:"u4";i:4;s:2:"u5";i:5;s:2:"u6";i:6;s:2:"g4";i:7;s:2:"g5";i:8;s:2:"g6";}"
          "noSearch" => ""
          "cssClass" => "news-details"
          "sitemap" => "map_default"
          "hide" => "1"
          "guests" => ""
          "tabindex" => "0"
          "accesskey" => ""
          "published" => "1"
          "start" => ""
          "stop" => ""
          "catalogRoutingTable" => ""
          "catalogMasterTable" => ""
          "catalogChangeLanguageTable" => ""
          "catalogRouting" => ""
          "catalogSetAutoItem" => ""
          "catalogRoutingParameter" => null
          "catalogUseRouting" => ""
          "catalogUseChangeLanguage" => ""
          "catalogShowInBreadcrumb" => ""
          "catalogUseMaster" => ""
          "dlh_googlemaps_apikey" => ""
          "newsCategories_param" => ""
          "mainAlias" => "service"
          "mainTitle" => "Service"
          "mainPageTitle" => "Service"
          "parentAlias" => "steuer-recht"
          "parentTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "parentPageTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "folderUrl" => "service/steuer-recht/"
          "rootId" => "46"
          "rootAlias" => "marketsteel-de"
          "rootTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "rootPageTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "domain" => "www.marketsteel.de"
          "rootLanguage" => "de"
          "rootIsPublic" => true
          "rootIsFallback" => true
          "rootUseSSL" => "1"
          "rootFallbackLanguage" => "de"
          "trail" => array:4 [
            0 => "46"
            1 => "120"
            2 => "30"
            3 => "95"
          ]
        ]
        #arrModified: array:10 [
          "protected" => ""
          "groups" => null
          "layout" => "0"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "cache" => "0"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "language" => ""
          "dateFormat" => ""
          "timeFormat" => ""
          "datimFormat" => ""
        ]
        #arrRelations: array:6 [
          "jumpTo" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_page"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "groups" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_member_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasMany"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "layout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "mobileLayout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cuser" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cgroup" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
        ]
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: true
      }
    ]
    #blnPreventSaving: false
  }
  "count" => 0
  "text" => Closure {#514
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#487 …}
    use: {
      $id: "13116"
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "127 to 141"
  }
  "hasText" => Closure {#517
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#487 …}
    use: {
      $objArticle: NewsModel {#516 …}
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "143 to 146"
  }
  "hasTeaser" => true
  "hasMetaFields" => true
  "numberOfComments" => null
  "commentCount" => null
  "timestamp" => "1653868860"
  "datetime" => "2022-05-30T00:01:00+00:00"
  "width" => 790
  "height" => 456
  "arrSize" => array:7 [
    0 => 780
    1 => 450
    2 => 2
    3 => "width="780" height="450""
    "bits" => 8
    "channels" => 3
    "mime" => "image/jpeg"
  ]
  "imgSize" => " width="780" height="450""
  "picture" => array:4 [
    "img" => array:4 [
      "srcset" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg 1x, files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg 1.013x"
      "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
      "width" => 780
      "height" => 450
    ]
    "sources" => array:1 [
      0 => array:5 [
        "srcset" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "src" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "width" => 270
        "height" => 156
        "media" => "(max-width: 270px)"
      ]
    ]
    "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
    "title" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  ]
  "floatClass" => " float_above"
  "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
  "linkTitle" => ""
  "addBefore" => true
  "margin" => ""
  "categories" => array:1 [
    22 => array:23 [
      "id" => "22"
      "pid" => "0"
      "sorting" => "2160"
      "tstamp" => "1537387193"
      "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
      "cssClass" => ""
      "description" => null
      "image" => null
      "hideInList" => "0"
      "hideInReader" => "0"
      "excludeInRelated" => "0"
      "jumpTo" => "0"
      "published" => "1"
      "model" => NewsCategoryModel {#559
        #arrData: array:15 [
          "id" => "22"
          "pid" => "0"
          "sorting" => "2160"
          "tstamp" => "1537387193"
          "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
          "cssClass" => ""
          "description" => null
          "image" => null
          "hideInList" => "0"
          "hideInReader" => "0"
          "excludeInRelated" => "0"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "published" => "1"
        ]
        #arrModified: []
        #arrRelations: []
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: false
      }
      "name" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "class" => "news_category_22 category_22"
      "href" => ""
      "hrefWithParam" => ""
      "targetPage" => null
      "linkTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "generateUrl" => Closure {#558
        class: "Codefog\NewsCategoriesBundle\EventListener\TemplateListener"
        this: TemplateListener {#554 …}
        parameters: {
          $page: {
            typeHint: "Contao\PageModel"
          }
          $absolute: {
            default: false
          }
        }
        use: {
          $category: NewsCategoryModel {#559}
        }
        file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/codefog/contao-news_categories/src/EventListener/TemplateListener.php"
        line: "145 to 147"
      }
    ]
  ]
  "categoriesList" => array:1 [
    22 => "Trends/Hintergrund"
  ]
]

Verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung

von unsem Gastkommentator

Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz

Die verbilligte Vermietung einer Wohnung zu Wohnzwecken ist unschädlich bzw. gilt als vollentgeltlich, wenn das Entgelt mindestens 66 % der ortsüblichen Miete beträgt. Das Finanzgericht Baden-Württemberg hat das bei einer Vermietung eines aufwendig gestalteten Wohngebäudes allerdings jüngst anders gesehen und eine Totalüberschussprognose gefordert.

Gegen die Entscheidung des Finanzgerichts ist die Revision anhängig. Somit kann der Bundesfinanzhof nun klären, ob bei einer Vermietung mit mindestens 66 % der ortsüblichen Miete eine Totalüberschussprognose erforderlich ist, wenn es sich um ein aufwendig gestaltetes Wohngebäude (im konkreten Streitfall: Einfamilienhaus mit weit über 250 qm Wohnfläche) handelt.

Hintergrund und Regelung ab 2021

Bei einer verbilligten Überlassung einer Wohnung zu Wohnzwecken (z. B. an Angehörige) ist eine Entgeltlichkeitsgrenze einzuhalten, um den vollen Werbungskostenabzug zu sichern. Beträgt das Entgelt mindestens 66 % der ortsüblichen Miete, ist diese Grenze erfüllt.

Merke | Seit 2021 ist ein voller Werbungskostenabzug aber auch bei einem geringeren Entgelt möglich: Beträgt es 50 % und mehr, jedoch weniger als 66 % der ortsüblichen Miete, ist eine Totalüberschussprognoseprüfung vorzunehmen. Fällt diese positiv aus, ist Einkunftserzielungsabsicht zu unterstellen und der volle Werbungskostenabzug ist möglich. Anderenfalls ist von einer Einkunftserzielungsabsicht nur für den entgeltlich vermieteten Teil auszugehen und die Kosten sind aufzuteilen.

Quelle |FG Baden-Württemberg, Urteil vom 22.1.2021, Az. 5 K 1938/19, Rev. BFH: Az. IX R 17/21, unter www.iww.de, Abruf-Nr. 226476

Information zum Autor:

Die Steuerkanzlei Markus Schmetz berät kleine und mittelständische Unternehmen, Existenzgründer und Privatpersonen aus der Region Düsseldorf. Fundiertes Fachwissen und fachübergreifende Kontakte sind die Erfolgsgaranten.

mehr Information

Zurück