array:66 [
  "id" => "13115"
  "pid" => "12"
  "tstamp" => "1653225861"
  "headline" => "Stillhaltergeschäfte"
  "alias" => "stillhaltergeschäften"
  "author" => "von unsem Gastkommentator"
  "date" => "18.05.2022"
  "time" => "1652832060"
  "subheadline" => ""
  "teaser" => "<p>Vereinnahmung einer Stillhalterprämie und Zahlung der Glattstellungsprämie.</p>"
  "addImage" => true
  "overwriteMeta" => ""
  "singleSRC" => "files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg"
  "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "imageTitle" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "size" => "a:3:{i:0;s:0:"";i:1;s:0:"";i:2;s:0:"";}"
  "imagemargin" => "a:5:{s:6:"bottom";s:0:"";s:4:"left";s:0:"";s:5:"right";s:0:"";s:3:"top";s:0:"";s:4:"unit";s:0:"";}"
  "imageUrl" => ""
  "fullsize" => false
  "caption" => ""
  "floating" => "above"
  "addEnclosure" => ""
  "enclosure" => []
  "source" => "default"
  "jumpTo" => "0"
  "articleId" => "0"
  "url" => "https://www.marketsteel.de/files/recht/Steuerausblick%202021.pdf"
  "target" => ""
  "cssClass" => ""
  "noComments" => ""
  "featured" => ""
  "published" => "1"
  "start" => "1652832000"
  "stop" => ""
  "lazyDisable" => ""
  "syncArchive" => "8"
  "uuid" => "9fe983b2-b797-4752-92cb-723a538e69e3"
  "class" => " news_category_22 category_22"
  "newsHeadline" => "Stillhaltergeschäfte"
  "subHeadline" => ""
  "hasSubHeadline" => false
  "linkHeadline" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/stillhaltergesch%C3%A4ften.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Stillhaltergeschäfte" itemprop="url">Stillhaltergeschäfte</a>"
  "more" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/stillhaltergesch%C3%A4ften.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Stillhaltergeschäfte" itemprop="url">read more<span class="invisible"> Stillhaltergeschäfte</span></a>"
  "link" => "steuer-recht-details/stillhaltergesch%C3%A4ften.html"
  "archive" => NewsArchiveModel {#497
    #arrData: array:27 [
      "id" => "12"
      "tstamp" => "1605357702"
      "title" => "DE - Recht"
      "jumpTo" => "95"
      "protected" => ""
      "groups" => null
      "allowComments" => ""
      "notify" => "notify_admin"
      "sortOrder" => "ascending"
      "perPage" => "0"
      "moderate" => ""
      "bbcode" => ""
      "requireLogin" => ""
      "disableCaptcha" => ""
      "categories" => null
      "limitCategories" => "0"
      "syncFilesDir" => b")LÃѧo\x11ê—×Hß7\x1C7P"
      "syncUpdate" => ""
      "syncCron" => ""
      "ignoreDuplicateAliases" => ""
      "syncUnpublished" => ""
      "syncLimitCategories" => null
      "syncArchives" => "a:1:{i:0;s:1:"8";}"
      "syncSourceUrl" => "http://de.market-steel.com"
      "syncTarget" => "1"
      "syncFixRelativeUrls" => ""
      "syncSource" => ""
    ]
    #arrModified: []
    #arrRelations: array:2 [
      "jumpTo" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_page"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasOne"
        "load" => "eager"
      ]
      "groups" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_member_group"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasMany"
        "load" => "lazy"
      ]
    ]
    #arrRelated: array:1 [
      "jumpTo" => PageModel {#435
        #blnDetailsLoaded: true
        #arrData: array:80 [
          "id" => "95"
          "pid" => "30"
          "sorting" => "128"
          "tstamp" => "1604347139"
          "title" => "Steuer & Recht Details"
          "alias" => "steuer-recht-details"
          "type" => "regular"
          "pageTitle" => ""
          "language" => "de"
          "robots" => "index,follow"
          "description" => null
          "redirect" => "permanent"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "redirectBack" => ""
          "url" => ""
          "target" => ""
          "dns" => ""
          "staticFiles" => ""
          "staticPlugins" => ""
          "fallback" => ""
          "adminEmail" => ""
          "dateFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "timeFormat" => "H:i:s"
          "datimFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "createSitemap" => ""
          "sitemapName" => ""
          "useSSL" => ""
          "autoforward" => ""
          "protected" => false
          "groups" => false
          "includeLayout" => ""
          "layout" => "9"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "includeCache" => ""
          "cache" => "43200"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "includeChmod" => ""
          "cuser" => "0"
          "cgroup" => "0"
          "chmod" => "a:9:{i:0;s:2:"u1";i:1;s:2:"u2";i:2;s:2:"u3";i:3;s:2:"u4";i:4;s:2:"u5";i:5;s:2:"u6";i:6;s:2:"g4";i:7;s:2:"g5";i:8;s:2:"g6";}"
          "noSearch" => ""
          "cssClass" => "news-details"
          "sitemap" => "map_default"
          "hide" => "1"
          "guests" => ""
          "tabindex" => "0"
          "accesskey" => ""
          "published" => "1"
          "start" => ""
          "stop" => ""
          "catalogRoutingTable" => ""
          "catalogMasterTable" => ""
          "catalogChangeLanguageTable" => ""
          "catalogRouting" => ""
          "catalogSetAutoItem" => ""
          "catalogRoutingParameter" => null
          "catalogUseRouting" => ""
          "catalogUseChangeLanguage" => ""
          "catalogShowInBreadcrumb" => ""
          "catalogUseMaster" => ""
          "dlh_googlemaps_apikey" => ""
          "newsCategories_param" => ""
          "mainAlias" => "service"
          "mainTitle" => "Service"
          "mainPageTitle" => "Service"
          "parentAlias" => "steuer-recht"
          "parentTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "parentPageTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "folderUrl" => "service/steuer-recht/"
          "rootId" => "46"
          "rootAlias" => "marketsteel-de"
          "rootTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "rootPageTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "domain" => "www.marketsteel.de"
          "rootLanguage" => "de"
          "rootIsPublic" => true
          "rootIsFallback" => true
          "rootUseSSL" => "1"
          "rootFallbackLanguage" => "de"
          "trail" => array:4 [
            0 => "46"
            1 => "120"
            2 => "30"
            3 => "95"
          ]
        ]
        #arrModified: array:10 [
          "protected" => ""
          "groups" => null
          "layout" => "0"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "cache" => "0"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "language" => ""
          "dateFormat" => ""
          "timeFormat" => ""
          "datimFormat" => ""
        ]
        #arrRelations: array:6 [
          "jumpTo" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_page"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "groups" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_member_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasMany"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "layout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "mobileLayout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cuser" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cgroup" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
        ]
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: true
      }
    ]
    #blnPreventSaving: false
  }
  "count" => 0
  "text" => Closure {#509
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#335 …}
    use: {
      $id: "13115"
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "127 to 141"
  }
  "hasText" => Closure {#512
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#335 …}
    use: {
      $objArticle: NewsModel {#511 …}
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "143 to 146"
  }
  "hasTeaser" => true
  "hasMetaFields" => true
  "numberOfComments" => null
  "commentCount" => null
  "timestamp" => "1652832060"
  "datetime" => "2022-05-18T00:01:00+00:00"
  "width" => 790
  "height" => 456
  "arrSize" => array:7 [
    0 => 780
    1 => 450
    2 => 2
    3 => "width="780" height="450""
    "bits" => 8
    "channels" => 3
    "mime" => "image/jpeg"
  ]
  "imgSize" => " width="780" height="450""
  "picture" => array:4 [
    "img" => array:4 [
      "srcset" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg 1x, files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg 1.013x"
      "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
      "width" => 780
      "height" => 450
    ]
    "sources" => array:1 [
      0 => array:5 [
        "srcset" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "src" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "width" => 270
        "height" => 156
        "media" => "(max-width: 270px)"
      ]
    ]
    "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
    "title" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  ]
  "floatClass" => " float_above"
  "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
  "linkTitle" => ""
  "addBefore" => true
  "margin" => ""
  "categories" => array:1 [
    22 => array:23 [
      "id" => "22"
      "pid" => "0"
      "sorting" => "2160"
      "tstamp" => "1537387193"
      "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
      "cssClass" => ""
      "description" => null
      "image" => null
      "hideInList" => "0"
      "hideInReader" => "0"
      "excludeInRelated" => "0"
      "jumpTo" => "0"
      "published" => "1"
      "model" => NewsCategoryModel {#554
        #arrData: array:15 [
          "id" => "22"
          "pid" => "0"
          "sorting" => "2160"
          "tstamp" => "1537387193"
          "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
          "cssClass" => ""
          "description" => null
          "image" => null
          "hideInList" => "0"
          "hideInReader" => "0"
          "excludeInRelated" => "0"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "published" => "1"
        ]
        #arrModified: []
        #arrRelations: []
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: false
      }
      "name" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "class" => "news_category_22 category_22"
      "href" => ""
      "hrefWithParam" => ""
      "targetPage" => null
      "linkTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "generateUrl" => Closure {#553
        class: "Codefog\NewsCategoriesBundle\EventListener\TemplateListener"
        this: TemplateListener {#549 …}
        parameters: {
          $page: {
            typeHint: "Contao\PageModel"
          }
          $absolute: {
            default: false
          }
        }
        use: {
          $category: NewsCategoryModel {#554}
        }
        file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/codefog/contao-news_categories/src/EventListener/TemplateListener.php"
        line: "145 to 147"
      }
    ]
  ]
  "categoriesList" => array:1 [
    22 => "Trends/Hintergrund"
  ]
]

Stillhaltergeschäfte

von unsem Gastkommentator

Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz

Seit der Abgeltungsteuer sind bei Stillhaltergeschäften mit periodenüberschreitendem Zu- und Abfluss die erhaltenen Stillhalterprämien bei ihrem Zufluss zu versteuern. Aufwendungen für Glattstellungsgeschäfte sind hingegen grundsätzlich erst im Zeitpunkt ihres Abflusses zu berücksichtigen. Das hat das Finanzgericht München entschieden.

  • 20 Abs. 1 Nr. 11 Einkommensteuergesetz (EStG) ordnet eine „getrennte“ Besteuerung der Stillhalterprämie und der Glattstellungsgeschäfte an, ohne den Barausgleich zu regeln. Die Vorschrift bietet keine Grundlage, um von den allgemeinen Grundsätzen abzuweichen, in welchem Zeitpunkt Zu- und Abflüsse zu berücksichtigen sind.

Eine Glattstellung liegt vor, wenn der Stillhalter eine Option der gleichen Art unter Closing-Vermerk kauft, wie er sie zuvor verkauft hat. Eine echte (beendende) Glattstellung ist gegeben, wenn das Glattstellungsgeschäft ein betrags- und fristenkongruentes Gegengeschäft ist, mit dem der Stillhalter seine Verpflichtung aus der Option zum Erlöschen bringt. Hierzu erwirbt der Stillhalter genau die Option, die er zuvor einem anderen eingeräumt hat, und macht durch den Glattstellungsvermerk (Closing-Order) eine Aufrechnung geltend.

Beachten Sie | Ob Gegengeschäfte ohne einen Glattstellungsvermerk als gegenläufige Geschäfte unter § 20 Abs. 1 Nr. 11 EStG fallen, konnte das Finanzgericht offenlassen.

Quelle |FG München, Urteil vom 28.9.2021, Az. 6 K 1458/19, unter www.iww.de, Abruf-Nr. 226477

Information zum Autor:

Die Steuerkanzlei Markus Schmetz berät kleine und mittelständische Unternehmen, Existenzgründer und Privatpersonen aus der Region Düsseldorf. Fundiertes Fachwissen und fachübergreifende Kontakte sind die Erfolgsgaranten.

mehr Information

Zurück