array:66 [
  "id" => "13981"
  "pid" => "12"
  "tstamp" => "1657905008"
  "headline" => "Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht"
  "alias" => "bundesfinanzhof-bestätigt-seine-rechtsprechung-zur-einkünfteerzielungsabsicht"
  "author" => "von Markus Schmetz, Steuerberater"
  "date" => "08.09.2022"
  "time" => "1662595260"
  "subheadline" => ""
  "teaser" => "<p>Bei einer auf Dauer angelegten, auf Wohnimmobilien bezogenen Vermietungstätigkeit ist typisierend von einer Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht (= keine Liebhaberei) auszugehen.</p>"
  "addImage" => true
  "overwriteMeta" => ""
  "singleSRC" => "files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg"
  "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "imageTitle" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  "size" => "a:3:{i:0;s:0:"";i:1;s:0:"";i:2;s:0:"";}"
  "imagemargin" => "a:5:{s:6:"bottom";s:0:"";s:4:"left";s:0:"";s:5:"right";s:0:"";s:3:"top";s:0:"";s:4:"unit";s:0:"";}"
  "imageUrl" => ""
  "fullsize" => false
  "caption" => ""
  "floating" => "above"
  "addEnclosure" => ""
  "enclosure" => []
  "source" => "default"
  "jumpTo" => "0"
  "articleId" => "0"
  "url" => "https://www.marketsteel.de/files/recht/Steuerausblick%202021.pdf"
  "target" => ""
  "cssClass" => ""
  "noComments" => ""
  "featured" => ""
  "published" => "1"
  "start" => "1662595200"
  "stop" => ""
  "lazyDisable" => ""
  "syncArchive" => "8"
  "uuid" => "0ddc992a-61e5-4528-9d9f-a9f405673d7a"
  "class" => " news_category_22 category_22"
  "newsHeadline" => "Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht"
  "subHeadline" => ""
  "hasSubHeadline" => false
  "linkHeadline" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/bundesfinanzhof-best%C3%A4tigt-seine-rechtsprechung-zur-eink%C3%BCnfteerzielungsabsicht.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht" itemprop="url">Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht</a>"
  "more" => "<a href="steuer-recht-details/bundesfinanzhof-best%C3%A4tigt-seine-rechtsprechung-zur-eink%C3%BCnfteerzielungsabsicht.html" title="Den Artikel lesen: Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht" itemprop="url">read more<span class="invisible"> Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht</span></a>"
  "link" => "steuer-recht-details/bundesfinanzhof-best%C3%A4tigt-seine-rechtsprechung-zur-eink%C3%BCnfteerzielungsabsicht.html"
  "archive" => NewsArchiveModel {#502
    #arrData: array:27 [
      "id" => "12"
      "tstamp" => "1605357702"
      "title" => "DE - Recht"
      "jumpTo" => "95"
      "protected" => ""
      "groups" => null
      "allowComments" => ""
      "notify" => "notify_admin"
      "sortOrder" => "ascending"
      "perPage" => "0"
      "moderate" => ""
      "bbcode" => ""
      "requireLogin" => ""
      "disableCaptcha" => ""
      "categories" => null
      "limitCategories" => "0"
      "syncFilesDir" => b")LÃѧo\x11ê—×Hß7\x1C7P"
      "syncUpdate" => ""
      "syncCron" => ""
      "ignoreDuplicateAliases" => ""
      "syncUnpublished" => ""
      "syncLimitCategories" => null
      "syncArchives" => "a:1:{i:0;s:1:"8";}"
      "syncSourceUrl" => "http://de.market-steel.com"
      "syncTarget" => "1"
      "syncFixRelativeUrls" => ""
      "syncSource" => ""
    ]
    #arrModified: []
    #arrRelations: array:2 [
      "jumpTo" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_page"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasOne"
        "load" => "eager"
      ]
      "groups" => array:4 [
        "table" => "tl_member_group"
        "field" => "id"
        "type" => "hasMany"
        "load" => "lazy"
      ]
    ]
    #arrRelated: array:1 [
      "jumpTo" => PageModel {#418
        #blnDetailsLoaded: true
        #arrData: array:80 [
          "id" => "95"
          "pid" => "30"
          "sorting" => "128"
          "tstamp" => "1604347139"
          "title" => "Steuer & Recht Details"
          "alias" => "steuer-recht-details"
          "type" => "regular"
          "pageTitle" => ""
          "language" => "de"
          "robots" => "index,follow"
          "description" => null
          "redirect" => "permanent"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "redirectBack" => ""
          "url" => ""
          "target" => ""
          "dns" => ""
          "staticFiles" => ""
          "staticPlugins" => ""
          "fallback" => ""
          "adminEmail" => ""
          "dateFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "timeFormat" => "H:i:s"
          "datimFormat" => "d.m.Y"
          "createSitemap" => ""
          "sitemapName" => ""
          "useSSL" => ""
          "autoforward" => ""
          "protected" => false
          "groups" => false
          "includeLayout" => ""
          "layout" => "9"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "includeCache" => ""
          "cache" => "43200"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "includeChmod" => ""
          "cuser" => "0"
          "cgroup" => "0"
          "chmod" => "a:9:{i:0;s:2:"u1";i:1;s:2:"u2";i:2;s:2:"u3";i:3;s:2:"u4";i:4;s:2:"u5";i:5;s:2:"u6";i:6;s:2:"g4";i:7;s:2:"g5";i:8;s:2:"g6";}"
          "noSearch" => ""
          "cssClass" => "news-details"
          "sitemap" => "map_default"
          "hide" => "1"
          "guests" => ""
          "tabindex" => "0"
          "accesskey" => ""
          "published" => "1"
          "start" => ""
          "stop" => ""
          "catalogRoutingTable" => ""
          "catalogMasterTable" => ""
          "catalogChangeLanguageTable" => ""
          "catalogRouting" => ""
          "catalogSetAutoItem" => ""
          "catalogRoutingParameter" => null
          "catalogUseRouting" => ""
          "catalogUseChangeLanguage" => ""
          "catalogShowInBreadcrumb" => ""
          "catalogUseMaster" => ""
          "dlh_googlemaps_apikey" => ""
          "newsCategories_param" => ""
          "mainAlias" => "service"
          "mainTitle" => "Service"
          "mainPageTitle" => "Service"
          "parentAlias" => "steuer-recht"
          "parentTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "parentPageTitle" => "Steuer & Recht"
          "folderUrl" => "service/steuer-recht/"
          "rootId" => "46"
          "rootAlias" => "marketsteel-de"
          "rootTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "rootPageTitle" => "marketSTEEL de"
          "domain" => "www.marketsteel.de"
          "rootLanguage" => "de"
          "rootIsPublic" => true
          "rootIsFallback" => true
          "rootUseSSL" => "1"
          "rootFallbackLanguage" => "de"
          "trail" => array:4 [
            0 => "46"
            1 => "120"
            2 => "30"
            3 => "95"
          ]
        ]
        #arrModified: array:10 [
          "protected" => ""
          "groups" => null
          "layout" => "0"
          "mobileLayout" => "0"
          "cache" => "0"
          "clientCache" => "0"
          "language" => ""
          "dateFormat" => ""
          "timeFormat" => ""
          "datimFormat" => ""
        ]
        #arrRelations: array:6 [
          "jumpTo" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_page"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "groups" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_member_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasMany"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "layout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "mobileLayout" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_layout"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cuser" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
          "cgroup" => array:4 [
            "table" => "tl_user_group"
            "field" => "id"
            "type" => "hasOne"
            "load" => "lazy"
          ]
        ]
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: true
      }
    ]
    #blnPreventSaving: false
  }
  "count" => 0
  "text" => Closure {#514
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#487 …}
    use: {
      $id: "13981"
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "127 to 141"
  }
  "hasText" => Closure {#517
    class: "Contao\ModuleNews"
    this: ModuleNewsReader {#487 …}
    use: {
      $objArticle: NewsModel {#516 …}
    }
    file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/contao/news-bundle/src/Resources/contao/modules/ModuleNews.php"
    line: "143 to 146"
  }
  "hasTeaser" => true
  "hasMetaFields" => true
  "numberOfComments" => null
  "commentCount" => null
  "timestamp" => "1662595260"
  "datetime" => "2022-09-08T00:01:00+00:00"
  "width" => 790
  "height" => 456
  "arrSize" => array:7 [
    0 => 780
    1 => 450
    2 => 2
    3 => "width="780" height="450""
    "bits" => 8
    "channels" => 3
    "mime" => "image/jpeg"
  ]
  "imgSize" => " width="780" height="450""
  "picture" => array:4 [
    "img" => array:4 [
      "srcset" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg 1x, files/people/portrait_markus-schmetz.jpg 1.013x"
      "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
      "width" => 780
      "height" => 450
    ]
    "sources" => array:1 [
      0 => array:5 [
        "srcset" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "src" => "assets/images/4/portrait_markus-schmetz-b8e7d987.jpg"
        "width" => 270
        "height" => 156
        "media" => "(max-width: 270px)"
      ]
    ]
    "alt" => "Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
    "title" => "Steuerberater Markus Schmetz"
  ]
  "floatClass" => " float_above"
  "src" => "assets/images/3/portrait_markus-schmetz-682d13a5.jpg"
  "linkTitle" => ""
  "addBefore" => true
  "margin" => ""
  "categories" => array:1 [
    22 => array:23 [
      "id" => "22"
      "pid" => "0"
      "sorting" => "2160"
      "tstamp" => "1537387193"
      "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
      "cssClass" => ""
      "description" => null
      "image" => null
      "hideInList" => "0"
      "hideInReader" => "0"
      "excludeInRelated" => "0"
      "jumpTo" => "0"
      "published" => "1"
      "model" => NewsCategoryModel {#559
        #arrData: array:15 [
          "id" => "22"
          "pid" => "0"
          "sorting" => "2160"
          "tstamp" => "1537387193"
          "title" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "frontendTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
          "alias" => "trends-hintergrund"
          "cssClass" => ""
          "description" => null
          "image" => null
          "hideInList" => "0"
          "hideInReader" => "0"
          "excludeInRelated" => "0"
          "jumpTo" => "0"
          "published" => "1"
        ]
        #arrModified: []
        #arrRelations: []
        #arrRelated: []
        #blnPreventSaving: false
      }
      "name" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "class" => "news_category_22 category_22"
      "href" => ""
      "hrefWithParam" => ""
      "targetPage" => null
      "linkTitle" => "Trends/Hintergrund"
      "generateUrl" => Closure {#558
        class: "Codefog\NewsCategoriesBundle\EventListener\TemplateListener"
        this: TemplateListener {#554 …}
        parameters: {
          $page: {
            typeHint: "Contao\PageModel"
          }
          $absolute: {
            default: false
          }
        }
        use: {
          $category: NewsCategoryModel {#559}
        }
        file: "/mnt/web412/b0/17/59421617/htdocs/marketsteel_international/vendor/codefog/contao-news_categories/src/EventListener/TemplateListener.php"
        line: "145 to 147"
      }
    ]
  ]
  "categoriesList" => array:1 [
    22 => "Trends/Hintergrund"
  ]
]

Bundesfinanzhof bestätigt seine Rechtsprechung zur Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht

von Markus Schmetz, Steuerberater

Portrait von Steuerberater Markus Schmetz

Bei einer auf Dauer angelegten, auf Wohnimmobilien bezogenen Vermietungstätigkeit ist typisierend von einer Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht (= keine Liebhaberei) auszugehen. Ob der Steuerpflichtige tatsächlich einen Totalüberschuss erzielt, ist unerheblich, da es zu einer dies überprüfenden Prognose nicht kommt. In einem aktuellen Beschluss hat der Bundesfinanzhof damit seine bisherige Rechtsprechung bestätigt.

Beachten Sie | Demgegenüber gilt bei Immobilien, die nicht Wohnzwecken dienen (sogenannte Gewerbeimmobilien), die Typisierung der Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht nicht. Hier muss im Einzelfall geprüft werden, ob der Steuerpflichtige beabsichtigt hat, auf die voraussichtliche Dauer der Nutzung einen Überschuss der Einnahmen über die Werbungskosten zu erzielen. Den Steuerpflichtigen trifft insoweit die objektive Beweislast (Feststellungslast) für das Vorliegen der Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht.

Quelle | BFH, Beschluss vom 29.3.2022, Az. IX B 18/21, unter www.iww.de, Abruf-Nr. 229143

Information zum Autor:

Die Steuerkanzlei Markus Schmetz berät kleine und mittelständische Unternehmen, Existenzgründer und Privatpersonen aus der Region Düsseldorf. Fundiertes Fachwissen und fachübergreifende Kontakte sind die Erfolgsgaranten.

mehr Information

Zurück